Skip to content

Am I the Jerk for automating a company process without boss’s approval and now facing termination?

Okay, here we go. This is a lot, but I need some outside opinions because I just don’t get it. My boss is acting like I committed a federal crime and I just… I was trying to help. I really was.

So, I work in operations for a mid-sized company that deals with a lot of different vendors and products. It’s a busy place, and honestly, the systems we use are, to put it mildly, outdated. Like, seriously, we’re talking about processes that feel like they were designed in the 90s and just sort of… patched together over the years. Everyone complains about it. EVERYONE. There are so many redundant steps, so much manual data entry that could easily be automated, and just general inefficiencies that slow everything down.

I’ve been there for a couple of years now, and I’ve always been someone who likes to find solutions. I see a problem, I try to fix it. It’s just how my brain works. I’ve brought up suggestions in team meetings, sent emails to my boss, even put together a little presentation once about how we could improve our inventory tracking. Every single time, it’s the same response: “Thanks for the feedback, [My Name],” or “We’ll look into it,” but nothing ever changes. It’s incredibly frustrating to watch obvious problems just fester because no one wants to rock the boat or invest in fixing things properly.

The biggest pain point, and I mean the biggest, is our supplier ordering process. We have this one critical component that we order from a specific vendor. The old system had us manually filling out a form, emailing it to a supervisor, who then had to log into a separate system to approve it, then manually forward it to the vendor. Then, when the order was confirmed, we’d get an email, and someone had to manually update our internal tracking sheet. It was absurdly slow. An order that should take five minutes often took hours, sometimes even a full day if someone was busy or out of the office. And if there was a typo at any point? Forget about it. Massive delays.

I saw a way to fix it. I really did. Our vendor has an online portal that’s actually pretty robust. You can place orders directly, track them, even set up automatic reorders for recurring items. It’s all secure, encrypted, everything you’d expect from a modern system. I figured, why are we doing all this manual back-and-forth when the vendor literally provides a better way?

So, about three weeks ago, I just… did it. I signed up for an account on the vendor’s portal using the company’s existing vendor ID and our general operations email. I spent a few hours on a slow Friday afternoon setting up a few templates for our most common orders. I linked it to our internal tracking sheet (the one I created in Google Sheets after the old Excel one kept getting corrupted, another “fix” nobody officially sanctioned but everyone uses now) so that when an order was placed on the portal, it would automatically update the sheet. No more manual emails, no more waiting for supervisor approval for standard stock orders (for special orders, I still planned to get approval, just not for the everyday stuff). It was beautiful. It cut out like, three steps and probably saved us a cumulative five to ten hours a week just on this one component.

I didn’t tell my boss immediately because I wanted to test it, show him how well it worked. I figured once he saw the efficiency, he’d be thrilled. I ran it for two weeks. We got all our components on time, sometimes even faster than before. No issues. I was feeling pretty proud.

Then, yesterday, it hit the fan. Apparently, a supervisor in another department, completely unrelated to these specific components, needed to access some historical ordering data for an audit. The old, manual system stored all the email chains and forms in a shared drive. My new system, of course, didn’t create those chains for the orders I placed. When they couldn’t find the documentation for the last two weeks of orders, they started digging. And that’s when my boss, Robert, found out.

He called me into his office, and I’ve never seen him so angry. He was yelling, asking what I thought I was doing, why I went “rogue,” why I “bypassed established protocols.” I tried to explain that I was streamlining things, making it more efficient, saving time and resources. I told him how everyone complains about the old system. I even showed him how the new setup worked, how easy it was, how it hadn’t caused any issues. He just kept cutting me off, saying I had no authority to make such changes, that I could have jeopardized our relationship with the vendor, that I created a “hole” in their audit trail, and that I was “lucky” the audit wasn’t for those specific components.

He said I broke company policy and that my “initiative” was actually a serious breach of protocol. He’s talking about disciplinary action, maybe even termination. Termination! For trying to make things better! I genuinely thought I was helping. I was solving a problem that everyone agreed was a problem. I wasn’t trying to cause trouble, I was trying to improve our workflow. Nobody got hurt, we didn’t lose money, we actually got our supplies faster.

So, was I wrong? I honestly don’t think I am. I believe I was doing what any good employee should do: identifying inefficiencies and fixing them. Robert is just too stuck in his ways to see the bigger picture. I was trying to innovate. He’s just mad because I went around him, but if he’d just listened to my suggestions in the first place, I wouldn’t have had to.

Am I The Jerk here? Please tell me I’m not crazy for thinking I was doing the right thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *