Skip to content

Category:

Am I The Jerk?

From family feuds to workplace drama, this is where we ask the ultimate question: “Was I out of line?” Explore stories of conflict and decide for yourself if the storyteller was justified or just plain wrong.

A Messy Escalation: Was I Wrong to Fling the Poo Back?

After months of asking my neighbor to stop letting her "yappy dog" use my front lawn as a private bathroom, I finally snapped. Instead of another polite request, I grabbed a shovel and delivered the "gift" back to her front door, at high velocity. Now she's threatening to call the cops, and my family thinks I went too far. Was this a fair trade, or am I the neighborhood menace?

My Brother Slept With My Fiancée, Then Asked for the Engagement Ring

I caught the love of my life in bed with my own brother. I kicked her out and kept the diamond ring, letting it gather dust in my closet for seven years. When I finally let my brother back into my life, he found the box while helping me move. His request? He wanted me to give him the ring, the same one he ruined my life for, so he could propose to someone else for free. That’s when I saw red.